Milwaukee woman charged in fake teacher case now accused of car theft
Updated: Oct. 12, 2026
MILWAUKEE (CBS 58) -- The woman accused of posing as a Milwaukee substitute teacher is now accused of stealing an SUV with a loaded gun inside.
Police say Amy Jones used a fake name to get into a Brookfield gym Friday. Once inside, she allegedly stole an energy drink, then swiped another customer's keys and drove off in his SUV. The owner says his loaded handgun was in the glovebox.
Jones was later arrested in Illinois.
She faces four new charges, including car theft, and two counts of felony bail jumping.
Published: Oct. 10, 2026
MILWAUKEE (CBS 58) — A Milwaukee woman charged with posing as a teacher to gain access to a Milwaukee high school and harassing students is back in custody after an alleged vehicle theft in Brookfield.
The Brookfield Police Department confirmed to CBS 58 that Amy Jones is accused of stealing a vehicle from a gym after allegedly using a fake name to gain access to the vehicle's keys.
Hours later, Jones was arrested following a crash in Oak Lawn, Illinois, a suburb south of Chicago.
The latest arrest comes just days after Jones appeared in Milwaukee County court in connection with the school case.
Earlier this week, a Milwaukee County court commissioner set a signature bond for Jones in that case.
Jones is accused of falsely representing herself to gain access to a Milwaukee high school before allegedly harassing students for several hours.
Additional details surrounding the alleged vehicle theft, crash and Jones' arrest were not immediately available.