Judge rejects RNC protest zone request in Milwaukee

 

MILWAUKEE (CBS 58) -- A federal judge has denied a request from the Coalition to March on the RNC to establish a protest zone outside the designated security area for the upcoming Republican National Convention, scheduled for Monday, July 15 through Thursday, July 18.

U.S. District Judge Brett Ludwig's decision was issued on Monday, July 8 and concluded that the City of Milwaukee's security plan for the convention, including restricted protest zones and an official parade route, is a reasonable measure to ensure public safety.

Security measures, including a pedestrian restricted perimeter and vehicle screening points, were established due to the high-profile nature of the event, which will be attended by key political figures requiring Secret Service protection. “We firmly believe that the City of Milwaukee delayed the release of their designated route so we would not have much time in court to litigate,” said Omar Flores, co-chair of the Coalition to March on the RNC.

The Coalition filed for an injunction to allow their preferred route, citing First and Fourteenth Amendment rights. The court, however, found that the city's plan, developed in coordination with the Secret Service, fairly accommodates free speech while addressing security concerns for the convention.

“While the courts have decided, exactly a week out, that the city is not infringing on our First Amendment rights. We are firm in our demand to march within sight and sound of the front doors of the Fiserv Forum,” said Flores.

The ruling allows the Coalition to hold its protest on the official parade route, which was granted for noon on July 15, but prevents them from using their requested route, which crosses the secure perimeter.

While the ruling rejected the expanded protest request, Ludwig did rule in their favor in part, by deciding that the city cannot revoke permits based solely on prior criminal records of protesters.

Protest organizers say despite the judge’s decision, they plan to march their own route without a permit. “We do have an updated march route that complies with the credentialed zone,” said Flores.

CBS 58 reached out to the mayor’s office and the Milwaukee Police Department for comment. They each sent the following statements:

From Milwaukee Mayor Cavalier Johnson’s office:

“The city respects the judge’s decision. All activity taking place in the vicinity of the convention will be monitored to make sure safety for everyone is paramount.”

From MPD:

“The Milwaukee Police Department respects the rights of all individuals who wish to peacefully express their First Amendment rights. We remain committed to preparing for a safe, secure and successful Republican National Convention.”

Protestors plan to meet at Red Arrow Park Monday, July 15, at 10 to organize their demonstration.