Parents of West Allis woman speak out after husband charged with her murder, 2 years later
MCSO/GoFundMe WEST ALLIS, Wis. (CBS 58) -- More than two years after a West Allis woman's death, her husband is now charged with her murder.
Benjamin Carpenter initially told investigators his wife's death was an accident, but prosecutors have since filed a first-degree intentional homicide charge against him.
Now, for the first time since the charges were filed, Erica Carpenter's parents are speaking publicly about their daughter, the investigation and their hopes for justice.
Debra and Michael Clarenbach say the past two years have been filled with grief and unanswered questions. They were beginning to heal from losing their only child when news of the criminal charges brought those emotions back.
"Erica was one of a kind," her mother, Debra Clarenbach, said.
The Clarenbachs say it took seven years for them to have Erica, and she made the most of every opportunity.
Her father, Michael Clarenbach, remembers her determination, including running the Milwaukee Marathon on her own during the Covid-19 pandemic after months of training.
"She ran the Milwaukee Marathon on her own during Covid," he said. "Because she had prepared for it for six months, and she says, 'I'm going to do it.'"
But more than two years after her death, her family says they're facing another wave of heartbreak.
"It was like the wounds were starting to heal, and they ripped the bandage off again," Michael Clarenbach said.
Prosecutors filed a first-degree intentional homicide charge against Carpenter on Tuesday.
According to the criminal complaint, Carpenter initially told police in October 2024 that Erica collapsed while doing laundry in the basement.
He told investigators he tried to carry her upstairs but dropped her, causing her to hit her head.
The criminal complaint also details alleged internet searches about crushing pills, text messages between the couple discussing powder in Erica's water and questions about life insurance.
Prosecutors also outlined an alleged extramarital relationship.
For Erica's parents, the investigation has revealed details they say they never expected.
"They turned over one rock, there was another rock, another rock. And then the next rock, they found more. They kept digging and digging," Debra Clarenbach said.
Michael Clarenbach said the allegations have changed how the family views the man they once knew.
"Completely blindsided," he said. "That it seemed like Ben had a dark side that we didn't know about."
Carpenter made his first court appearance Wednesday. During the hearing, Milwaukee County Court Commissioner Rosa Barillas referenced the investigation detailed in the criminal complaint.
While the charges have brought new questions, Erica's parents say their memories of their daughter remain unchanged.
Her mother says she continues to find reminders of Erica in unexpected places.
“On Erica's cremation container was a rainbow,” Debra Clarenbach said. “Ever since then, we see rainbow after rainbow, and if not a rainbow, we see a violin.”
The Clarenbachs say they know they will never get their daughter back. But they hope people remember Erica for the life she lived, not just the circumstances surrounding her death.
"I always tell her, 'Meet us at the pearly gates, Erica, please,'" Debra Clarenbach said.
Carpenter's bail was set at $500,000. He is scheduled to return to court next month.
