After days of wrenching testimony about camp deaths, judge says Camp Mystic’s flood site must remain untouched

Brandon Bell/Getty Images via CNN Newsource

By Andy Rose, Danya Gainor

(CNN) — Leaders of Camp Mystic — the Christian girls camp where 27 campers and counselors died in torrential flooding last summer — must continue to keep many damaged buildings untouched while a wrongful death lawsuit filed by the family of a child presumed dead moves forward, a Texas judge said Wednesday.

Travis County District Judge Maya Guerra Gamble said she would issue a new injunction order maintaining that camp leaders must preserve cabins and land affected by the flooding following three days of heart-wrenching testimony from several people, including members of the Eastland family, which has owned and operated Camp Mystic for decades.

The judge issued a similar injunction in March, and said Wednesday’s would include minor changes.

A status conference and discovery are scheduled for mid-May.

In their testimony, the Eastlands acknowledged they did not warn campers and counselors of rising floodwaters and dire weather warnings before cabins were overwhelmed July 4 and dozens of people became trapped or were swept away in the Texas Hill Country.

The temporary injunction stems from a wrongful death lawsuit against Camp Mystic brought by the family of Cile Steward, an 8-year-old camper whose body has not been recovered. The Steward family argued the case may ultimately hinge on critical physical evidence, such as campers’ sleeping cabins that were in place at the time of the disaster.

The Eastland family separately appealed the original temporary injunction to an appellate court in March.

Wednesday’s ruling will keep the Eastlands from cleaning up the site. The family has promised to never again use the damaged cabins to house children and still intends to open camp this summer at a different location on higher ground.

“Whether it is hubris, greed, grief, or just an overwhelming combination of all of those, they have this unmitigated desire to reopen this camp in a few weeks, and come hell or high water, they’re going to do it,” Brad Beckworth, the Stewards’ attorney, said about camp leaders Wednesday.

The future of Camp Mystic remains unclear. A separate investigation by the Texas Rangers and the Department of State Health Services into the deaths is underway, but no one has been charged. Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick recommended to state officials earlier this month that they deny a license to Camp Mystic while the investigation continues.

Parents urge regulators to decline camp’s license renewal in emotional letters

Parents of victims and survivors of the July 4 flooding echoed the lieutenant governor’s recommendation in emotional pleas to state regulators, asking them to reconsider renewing Camp Mystic’s license to operate, letters obtained by the Washington Post show.

The separate letters from six families allege their daughters were not properly evacuated and left in positions of “substantial risk,” and that the camp failed to inform parents the flood had happened, that other campers had been swept away or that others were found dead.

The letters ask the Texas Department of State Health Services to decline Camp Mystic’s license, and impose a hold on its renewal and operation until investigations are complete, their findings are made public and compliance is independently verified.

“This request is grounded in documented facts, statutory authority, and DSHS’s non-delegable duty to protect the health and safety of children. It is not a request for punishment, but for due diligence, accountability, and prevention of further harm,” the families wrote.

DSHS said it has received over 600 complaints related to the camp’s care of children during the 2025 season.

“DSHS is investigating the complaints that fall under the agency’s authority to investigate and sharing information with the Texas Department of Public Safety,” DSHS told CNN in a statement.

In an early April letter, DSHS told Camp Mystic Executive Director Tweety Eastland it is reviewing the camp’s application and emergency plan for “completeness and any deficiencies.”

DSHS also noted the state’s General Investigating Committee, a joint panel of the Texas Senate and House examining the deadly July 2025 flooding, is expected to wrap up its work in the coming weeks, with a hearing and report anticipated by early summer.

DSHS plans to conduct an on-site inspection as part of its complaint investigation, which will coincide with Camp Mystic’s renewal pre-inspection.

The pre-licensure inspection and onsite investigation visit has not been scheduled, DSHS told CNN.

?Findings from both the inspection and broader investigations could factor into the state’s decision on whether to approve the camp’s license for the upcoming season, according to the letter.

Several lawsuits claiming gross negligence have been filed against the camp and its owners since the July 4 disaster. Gamble said Wednesday she intends to hear the Stewards’ case first and move the trial up several months from its original April 2028 start date, and schedule other suits to follow.

The judge also said attorneys across the lawsuits will need to work together to coordinate deposing counselors, campers and staff only one time to minimize harm.

“We are not deposing teenage girls or children more than once. We’re just not. We’re going to do it right, we’re going to do it with quality court reporters and quality video,” Gamble said Wednesday. “I can’t imagine the argument that would convince me to bring any children into this court for the jury trial.”

An end to three days of emotional testimony

For three days in a row, members of the Eastland family provided emotional testimony as they recalled details of the disaster that killed 27 girls and counselors.

“I wish we had more information” before a decision was made to evacuate the camp, Camp Mystic director Edward Eastland testified Tuesday as he answered questions about the hours leading up to the catastrophic July 4 flooding at the camp’s Guadalupe River campus and the chaos that followed.

“All the information was there … if y’all had just stayed awake and looked, right?” responded Beckworth.

Husband and wife Britt and Catie Eastland, directors of the camp, also testified Wednesday alongside Camp Mystic’s night watchman Glen Juenke, who told the courtroom, “We did everything we could do with the amount of time we had.”

Juenke was questioned about his decision to not make an announcement telling the girls to go to higher ground as floodwaters began to overtake the camp in the early hours of July 4.

“That order was never given, correct?” Beckworth asked. “And 27 girls died because of that failure, correct?”

“Yes, sir,” Juenke responded.

On Tuesday during a somber moment on the stand, Mary Liz Eastland, Edward Eastland’s wife and the camp director in charge of the nursing staff, testified about her actions as the camp where she spent more than three decades — first as a camper then as a staff member — saw floodwaters rise.

“You knew the property. You knew the flood lines. You knew access points. Your children knew them. And these were first-year campers,” Christina Yarnell, another attorney representing the Steward family, said to Mary Liz Eastland. “You had 34 more years of experience than Cile. She needed your help, and you abandoned her, didn’t you?”

“Yes,” she replied.

The camp’s attorney, Mikal Watts, told CNN on Thursday the tragedy was exacerbated by the absence of a flood warning siren system he says had been proposed years earlier.

In 2017, Kerr County officials and the Upper Guadalupe River Authority sought $980,000 in FEMA funding for such a system but were denied, records show.

Without outside funding, the project “just didn’t get to the top of the list,” a former county official previously told CNN, despite past deadly floods. Commissioners revisited the idea in 2021 of a flood warning system including sirens and a possible $50,000 allocation — but it never moved forward.

“Had we had a siren system … it would have gone on, and they could have gotten the warning that everybody wants,” Watts said, adding, “All we needed was the siren warning from the technology that was asked for from the state of Texas a decade before.”

Watts also argued that such a warning could have provided critical time to evacuate campers and staff. “If we had gotten that warning, and we knew this tsunami of water, this wall of water, was coming, there was plenty of time to get those girls out of harm’s way,” he said.

“But that signal, that warning, was never delivered to the camp … there was no warning given to us to communicate over the loudspeakers. If that warning had come, that would have been one of the mechanisms to save these girls.”

He also pointed to changes made after the disaster, noting the state has since committed funding for improved flood detection systems. “After this tragedy, the state has allocated $50 million to put the very flood detection siren system that they should have put in in 2016,” Watts said.

“The good news is these systems are going in, and this will never happen again.”

CNN’s Pamela Brown, Isabel Rosales and Alaa Elassar contributed to this report.

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2026 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

CBS 58 Weather Forecast

Close