Wisconsin consumer advocates push for greater utility oversight and lower energy costs
MADISON (CBS 58) -- The ongoing effort to lower utility costs in Wisconsin is continuing as consumer advocates push for changes to how utility companies are overseen.
The Citizens Utility Board, along with national advocates, gathered in Madison for the Consumer Forum on Energy Affordability to discuss which policies they believe should be top of mind for lawmakers in the next legislative session.
The goal is to make energy more affordable for Wisconsin families as demand increases and energy systems continue to change.
"Energy is not a luxury, it’s a necessity," said Montre Moore, vice president of the Citizens Utility Board's board of directors.
Moore said new technologies, growing demand and investments in the energy system are creating both opportunities and challenges. He said economic growth should not come at the expense of families and that affordability should not be a partisan issue.
According to the Citizens Utility Board (CUB), Wisconsin is one of the only states in the country that does not oversee the long-term plans of utility companies. The organization hopes lawmakers will create more oversight of utilities in the next session.
CUB added that Wisconsin has the second-highest residential electricity rates in the Midwest and ranks 15th in the country for affordability. The organization also points to double-digit increases in utility costs over the last four years.
One reason the organization says costs are rising is a lack of integrated resource planning, which allows regulators to review utility companies' long-term plans and consider different options for meeting future energy demand.
"They are very siloed under the current approach, and most states have modernized their planning -- so it's time for Wisconsin to do that,” said Tom Content, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board.
Public Service Commission of Wisconsin Commissioner Kristy Nieto also highlighted integrated resource planning as one of three areas where the state could make changes.
Nieto said the cost of living, including utility bills, has grown faster than wages. She said Wisconsin has an opportunity to take the lead again by making changes to how utilities plan and operate.
“We are one of the only states that doesn’t oversee the utilities' big plans for investing in and building power plants,” Nieto said.
The other priorities include strengthening the rate-making process to ensure utility companies are held accountable for their spending and strengthening the capacity of consumer advocates and public interest organizations to participate in utility decisions.
As energy systems change and demand continues to grow, advocates at the forum are also laying out policy ideas they believe could help lower costs.
"This is a core anxiety of Americans today. We know that over the last several years, residential energy prices have increased over 40%,” said Tremain Phillips, a senior adviser at PowerLines.
The national organization PowerLines was established in 2024 as energy prices began to climb. Advocates say focusing on energy efficiency is one way states can reduce costs while also easing stress on the electrical grid.
Phillips said instead of continuing to build new infrastructure, states should look at how they can make better use of the systems already in place.
"Instead of building new polls and wires and generation power plant facilities, why not we invest in the existing assets we have and invest in behavioral changes that allows consumer to use the existing system more efficiently?” Phillips said.
Energy efficiency is also a policy goal for local organizations.
"Energy efficiency helps save money for the person and save the whole system at the same time, and provides more comfortable homes and apartments,” Content said.
Advocates say several factors are contributing to rising utility bills, including aging and inefficient electrical grids, extreme weather events and volatile fuel costs.
According to the organizations, utility companies across the country plan to spend $1.4 trillion between now and 2030 on capital expenditures. Consumer advocates say that level of investment makes increased oversight of utility companies even more important.